The story of the US presidents is part American history, part world history, a window into our future, a surefire conversation-starter, an endless supply of excellent trivia questions, and – for many – a hobby or obsession. Of course, items associated with former presidents can be extremely valuable to collectors.
Presidential memorabilia auctions can be as competitive as any. As our history marches on, certain presidents see a resurgence in interest or a historical reassessment. The same is true for items associated with presidents. A piece of memorabilia doesn’t need to have been owned by a president to be worth a good amount at auction. Even campaign buttons and posters can be worth a tidy little sum when sold to the right audience.
Examples of presidential collectibles
Presidential memorabilia can include any of the following (for starters):
- Pinback buttons
- Posters
- Banners
- Photographs
- Medals
- Letters
- Handwritten manuscripts of speeches
- Flags
If a miscellaneous item belonged to a president and there’s a compelling story behind it, it is probably worth taking a look at. Even ephemera and other items most people would consider disposable, like candy dishes, pens, or desk pieces, can be valuable at auction.
What makes a piece of presidential memorabilia valuable?
First, look at the era. In general, memorabilia from the World War II era and earlier will be valuable. Some John F. Kennedy memorabilia can also be desirable, though. As you might expect, memorabilia associated with early presidents (e.g. Jackson) or extremely consequential presidents (e.g. Lincoln) or both (e.g. Jefferson) typically is the most valuable. Of course, in the future it’s possible that memorabilia from more-recent presidents will become rarer, more storied, more sought-after, and more valuable at auction.
The stature of the president himself will make a difference as well. Memorabilia for presidents like Washington, Lincoln, and Teddy Roosevelt will fetch higher prices than those for Buchanan, Pierce, or Hayes. Nevertheless, even less-famous presidents have their places in some collections, and at times we are aware of certain organizations seeking specific pieces, which can help us help you sell your piece for more.
Supply also matters. Loads of generalized campaign buttons have been produced over the years, so they aren’t often as valuable as rarer pieces.
As usual, the condition of the item matters a great deal, too.
What is presidential memorabilia worth?
The most expensive piece of presidential memorabilia ever sold was George Washington’s copy of the US Constitution, including his signature, bookplate, and annotations, for $9,826,500.
Though your pieces might not top that record, the numbers can add up quickly and easily. Here are a few examples.
- A 1964 Harry S. Truman signed letter to an advisor, sold for $495
- John F. Kennedy’s White House Golf Ball sold for $1,250
- An original copy of the Chicago Daily Tribune with the famous headline of “Dewey Defeats Truman,” sold for $2,695
- A copy of Abraham Lincoln’s inaugural speech, a signed manuscript, sold for $1,320,000.
How can I sell my presidential memorabilia?
Work with us to get your pieces in front of serious collectors and organizations willing to pay top dollar. We avoid the deal-seekers in favor of people who know the history and true value of the pieces you have to sell.
Contact Central Mass Auctions to bring your piece of presidential history to auction.
